EcoSmart Insect Repellent with organic essential oils
I love summer – warm weather, short sleeves, long days, plenty of time to frolic in nature.
Of course, ‘nature’ also includes insects. And while I am generally a live-and-let-live sort of guy, I’m not eager to share my blood with mosquitoes and other biting creatures.
Lots of people feel the same way, which is why insect repellant is so popular. But the main chemical used in most insect repellants – DEET – may cause various health and environmental side effects.
I mean, DEET is pretty strong stuff. At high concentrations, it acts as a solvent that can dissolve plastics and other synthetic materials. Here’s a scientific look at the DEET molecule along with an interesting discussion about how you could ‘dissolve the world‘ with enough DEET!
Of course, I would prefer not to dissolve the world (or potentially experience memory loss, weakness, fatigue, etc.).
So what’s a Green consumer interested in preserving his own health and the health of the planet supposed to do to protect himself from biting bugs?
Luckily, there are a number of eco-friendly bug repellants on the market. I had the chance to try one of them – non-toxic and organic EcoSmart Insect Repellent.
EcoSmart Insect Repellent’s formula includes organic essential plant oils including rosemary oil, cinnamon leaf oil, lemongrass oil and geranoil. The company claims the pleasantly aromatic concoction will repel mosquitoes, ticks, gnats and other critters for hours.
How well does it work? Well, let me start by saying that I live in New York City, where the air quality is apparently toxic enough on its own to kill off most insects.
In other words, I don’t have to worry about getting bitten much even when my skin is un-sprayed with any repellent.
That said, there are of course some green spaces and pools of standing water (pothole puddles?) where mosquitoes might breed and there have been cases of West Nile Virus in the city in recent years.
So when I’ve taken dusky walks in parks this summer, I have applied some EcoSmart Insect Repellent just as a precaution. Result? No bites.
(I wanted to take the repellent with me on a recent trip to test it in a less urban area, but with airline restrictions on liquids in carry-on baggage, I was afraid I would get my EcoSmart confiscated, so I left it at home. I was OK, but sure enough, my wife suffered several mosquito bites. Darn you, TSA!)
So would I recommend EcoSmart Insect Repellent to a friend?
I certainly feel like it’s much safer and more eco-friendly than DEET, especially for children. My parents – both of whom are organic chemists – seemed quite nervous about spraying my siblings and me with DEET-containing repellents when we were kids in suburbia with woods around our house. In fact, my parents switched years ago to using bug zappers and citronella candles (now classified as a mild repellent) to keep mosquitos at bay. Of course, we still got bitten some, but at least I didn’t suffer any rare neurological side effects…
From a usage standpoint, EcoSmart Insect Repellent is great. It has a pleasant smell (aromatic and lemony, but not overpowering) and asborbs quickly with no greasiness.
From an effectiveness standpoint, it worked fine in what I consider to be a low-risk setting, but I can’t say for sure how well it would perform in let’s say in a swamp where you’re sweating heavily.
I will say this: I think your choice of repellent should depend on your assessment of risks and conditions. If you live in an area where mosquitos and other biting creatures are just an annoyance, I would strongly recommend at least trying EcoSmart or some other non-DEET repellent. If you live in or are visiting an area where mosquitos carry malaria and can be a major health risk, I would think more carefully about my repellent choice. On the other hand, I would personally be very anxious about long-term applications of DEET, so if you’re planning on spending lots of time in tropical, mosquito-infested areas, I would definitely investigate all sorts of non-toxic repellent and/or malaria prophylaxis options.
Don’t forget the risks from ticks either. Ticks are implicated in the spread of various nasty diseases including Lyme Disease and Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever.
So if you’re in an area where risks of tick-borne illness are high, you also want to use a repellent that works against ticks. The EcoSmart Insect Repellent claims to do that job too. DEET repellents have been shown to have some effectiveness against ticks, although sources such as the U.S. military apparently prefer an insecticide called permethrin that is actually applied to clothing (not skin).
Permethrin, of course, isn’t harmless either. Anything that can kill insects on contact probably will have some nasty qualities, and Pemethrin is no exception. The EPA says that the carcinogenic risks of permethrin for exposure to indoor treated surfaces, etc. were “above the agency’s Level Of Concern.”
In fact, prior to a Malaysian trip, I bought a permethrin spray thinking that I would treat my clothing with it, but quickly returned it to the store when I read the instructions on the spray can and saw that I would have to apply the product to clothing in an outdoor space where the clothing could be left for hours to dry. Something told me that would be a bit difficult in my high-rise Brooklyn apartment without any balcony.
Also, from an eco perspective, if permethrin kills ticks or mosquitos on contact, presumably it can also kill harmless or beneficial insects. Indeed, here’s what the EPA has to say on the topic:
Permethrin is highly toxic to both freshwater and estuarine aquatic organisms. Most agricultural, public health, and down-the-drain scenarios modeled resulted in exceedances in the acute risk quotient (RQ) for freshwater and estuarine fish, invertebrates, and sediment organisms. The agricultural and public health scenarios also showed the potential for chronic risks to estuarine and/or freshwater organisms. Further, there is a potential concern for direct effects to a variety of aquatic organisms.
and
Permethrin toxicity data show that the compound is highly toxic to honeybees, as well as other beneficial insects.
So…that sucks.
It seems to me that years ago, studies suggested that only high concentrations of DEET were truly effective at repelling mosquitoes, but I think more recent research has painted a different picture.
I found several studies cited online suggesting that natural substances from the Tauroniro tree or lemon eucalyptus oil also work quite well at repelling mosquitoes. Note that with some natural products, such as the lemon eucalyptus oil, you may need to reapply frequently for good protection.
Whatever product you choose, prevention and awareness are important components of protection from insect bites. You can often avoid mosquito bites by wearing long-sleeves and long pants (easier said than done in hot, humid climates) and staying indoors at times like dusk when mosquitoes tend to be most active. Some tick bites can be avoided by tucking pants into socks, staying away from tall grasses and wearing light colored clothing (to spot ticks crawling on clothes before they get to exposed skin).
Ultimately, the choice of the best insect repellent is a difficult question and one that each person has to decide for herself after weighing environmental risks and health risks from insect-borne illness and the repellents or insecticides themselves.
EcoSmart uses organic, essential oils to kill and repel insects
For myself, I’ll continue to use EcoSMART Organic Insect Repellent most of the time, but if I find myself in a situation where I’m extremely worried about the effect of a particular insect on my health, I may (guiltily) fall back on short-term use of a more toxic insect repellent or insecticide.
Meanwhile let’s hope that research bears fruit on efforts to find a vaccines for Lyme disease and malaria. Information on availability of Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever vaccine is somewhat contradictory, but the Encyclopedia Brittanica seems to suggest that such a vaccine does exist.
After all, it’s the pathogen the insects carry that’s most worrisome – not the insect bite itself. If I were protected against the pathogen, I would certainly shy away from the synthetic pesticides and rely exclusively on natural insecticides and repellents.
Meanwhile, I heartily encourage all readers to do their own research and try to stay abreast of the latest studies on the efficacy of natural alternatives to synethetic repellents and insecticides like DEET and permethrin.
Protecting our health is important, but we shouldn’t be cavalier about damaging the ecosystem or hurting beneficial insects and aquatic organisms in the process.
Where to Buy:
You can purchase EcoSMART Organic Insect Repellent directly from the EcoSMART website ($7 for 6 ounces) or in a 2-pack from Amazon.com.
EcoSmart Value Bundles provide savings on natural, organic insecticides and repellents
EcoSMART also sells a variety of insecticides based on organic plant oils including a Flying Insect Killer (peppermint oil, cinnamon oil and sesame oil – $8 for 14 ounces), Ant & Roach Killer (rosemary oil and cinnamon oil – $8 for 14 ounces – also supposedly works on silverfish, spiders, pill bugs and other crawling insects) and a Wasp & Hornet Killer (peppermint oil and a dash of 2-Phenethyl Propionate, $8 for 14 ounces).
I would certainly give any of these insecticides the first shot at handling any insect problem before using any insecticide that might have toxic effects on humans or other animals. I’d also point out that with some good preventative efforts (tight-fitting screens on windows, prompt trash removal, cleaning up crumbs and spills), you should be able to reduce the presence of insects in your home without any pesticide at all.
FYI, all the EcoSmart products the company sent me for review were labeled as Made in the U.S.A.
Note that EcoSmart also makes products using natural ingredients to tackle garden fungus and weeds.
If you want more information on EcoSmart products, I highly encourage you to check out the company’s informative website and/or read EcoSmart’s valuable blog that’s chock full of useful tips on protecting yourself, your home and your plants from various insects. I like how EcoSmart points out first how many insects are really benign — a refreshing viewpoint from a company that makes insecticides and repellents.